The big idea: You can weigh your body, scan your brain, count your cells. But can you weigh a thought? Can a scanner show the feel of your happiness?
The oldest question: That mismatch raises the oldest question here: is a person one thing (a body) or two (a body plus a mind)?
The two big answers
1
Dualism
You are TWO things: a physical body and a separate, non-physical mind.
2
Physicalism
You are ONE thing: a physical body. The mind just IS the brain at work.
Two things ↔ One thing
Free preview
This is the free notes preview
You're reading the free notes. Aimnova Pro unlocks the full study experience — and you can try it with your first topic free to keep:
- FlashcardsLock in vocabulary and key terms with spaced repetition.
- Practice questionsAnswer exam-style questions and get instant AI marking.
- Mock exams & past-paper vaultSit full mocks and see exactly how examiners award marks.
- Personalised study planA daily plan built around your exam date and weak areas.
Start Studying Free Full access to Aimnova Pro · cancel anytime
The most famous answer comes from René Descartes, who argued the mind and body are two different kinds of thing.
Descartes' dualism: Descartes noticed something odd. He could doubt that he had a body — maybe it's all a dream. But he could not doubt that he was thinking. So the thinking thing (the mind) and the body must be two different things — because one can be doubted while the other can't.
The body
- Physical
- Takes up space
- Has weight
- Obeys physics
The mind
- Non-physical
- No size
- No weight
- Not made of matter
Descartes' conclusion: You are, he says, a mind that has a body.
Checkpoint — Descartes: In one line: mind and body are two different kinds of thing — one physical, one not. That neat split is about to run into a serious problem.
See how examiners mark answers
Answer exam-style questions with model answers. Learn exactly what earns marks and what doesn't.
Try Exam Vault FreeYour first topic is free to keep • No credit card required
Dualism sounds tidy until you ask how the two halves ever touch.
How does a ghost move a body?: You decide to raise your hand — a mental event — and your hand goes up — a physical event. So the non-physical mind pushed the physical body.
But how?: A push needs something physical to do the pushing. If the mind has no size, no location, no energy, how does it ever move an arm? This is the interaction problem — and it's dualism's deepest weakness.
Dualism
- Strength: fits the feel that thoughts aren't physical
- Strength: explains why a thought can't be weighed
- Weakness: the interaction problem
- Weakness: where is this non-physical mind?
Physicalism
- Strength: fits brain science — damage the brain, change the mind
- Strength: no interaction problem (it's all physical)
- Weakness: but where's the FEEL in the physics? (see 1.3.1)
- Weakness: thoughts don't seem like brain-cells
Go further — higher-level insight: Neither side wins cleanly. Dualism explains the feel but can't explain interaction; physicalism explains interaction but struggles with the feel (Nagel's 'what it's like'). Many philosophers now look for a middle path — that unresolved tension is exactly what a top-band essay draws out.