aimnova.
DashboardMy LearningPaper MasteryStudy Plan

Aimnova site navigation

Stay in the loop

Get the latest study resources and updates

New features, study tips and exam insights — straight to your inbox.

IB Diploma

  • IB Past Papers
  • IB Study Notes
  • IB Question Bank
  • IB Mock Exams
  • IB Revision

IB Subjects

  • IB Math AA
  • IB Math AI
  • IB Economics
  • IB Business Management
  • IB Physics
  • IB Biology
  • View all IB subjects→

IB Past Papers

  • IB Math AA HL Past Papers
  • IB Math AA SL Past Papers
  • IB Math AI HL Past Papers
  • IB Math AI SL Past Papers
  • IB Economics HL Past Papers
  • IB Economics SL Past Papers
  • IB ESS Past Papers
  • View all past papers→

Study Resources

  • Study Notes
  • Question Bank
  • Mock Exams
  • Flashcards
  • Revision Guide
  • Exam Skills
  • Command Terms
  • Grade Calculator
  • Exam Timetable 2026

Aimnova

  • Features
  • Pricing
  • For Teachers
  • For Schools
  • For Parents
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Contact
aimnova.

AI-powered study platform for smarter revision, past-paper analysis and examiner-style feedback.

TermsPrivacyCookies·© 2026 Aimnova. All rights reserved.4d879c2

Aimnova is not affiliated with or endorsed by the International Baccalaureate Organization (IB).

NotesESS HLTopic 9.1What laws are
Back to ESS HL Topics
9.1.16 min read

What laws are (ESS HL)

IB Environmental Systems and Societies • Unit 9

Your first topic is free to keep

Know exactly what to write for full marks

Practice with exam questions and get AI feedback that shows you the perfect answer — what examiners want to see.

Start Free

Contents

  • What laws are at Higher Level
  • What a law is
  • Who makes laws: governments and communities
  • A law or only a guideline?
  • How laws are enforced
  • Exam-style question
What laws are at Higher Level: This statement is Higher Level only. It opens the environmental law lens: before asking what environmental law does, you need to know what makes any rule a law. The answer is who makes it and whether it can be enforced.

Practise this as you read

  • State the features of a law.
  • Outline how a named law is made and enforced.
  • Distinguish a law from a guideline or a voluntary pledge.

Free preview

This is the free notes preview

You're reading the free notes. Aimnova Pro unlocks the full study experience — and you can try it with your first topic free to keep:

  • FlashcardsLock in vocabulary and key terms with spaced repetition.
  • Practice questionsAnswer exam-style questions and get instant AI marking.
  • Mock exams & past-paper vaultSit full mocks and see exactly how examiners award marks.
  • Personalised study planA daily plan built around your exam date and weak areas.
Start Studying Free Full access to Aimnova Pro · cancel anytime
Rules with teeth: A law is a rule that governs human behaviour. It is made and enforced by a social or governmental authority. Environmental law is one kind of law.

The points to remember

  • A law is a rule: it says what people must or must not do.
  • It governs human behaviour: what people make, use, sell or throw away.
  • It is made by an authority: a government, or a community's own leaders.
  • It is enforced: someone checks, and breaking it brings a penalty.
Remember it as: Rule, behaviour, authority, enforced.

Rule

  • No one may make, import, sell or use plastic bags.

Behaviour

  • Shoppers and shops switch to paper, cloth and woven bags.

Authority

  • Rwanda's parliament passed the law in 2008.

Enforced

  • Bags are taken at the border and airport; shops that sell them are fined.

Feeling unprepared for exams?

Get a clear study plan, practice with real questions, and know exactly where you stand before exam day. No more guessing.

Get Exam Ready FreeYour first topic is free to keep • No credit card required

Most laws come from a government. A parliament passes an Act, and ministers or agencies add each regulation. But a community can also make and enforce rules: customary law.

Two kinds of authority

  • Governmental authority: a parliament passes Acts; ministers and agencies make regulations.
  • Social authority: a community's leaders make and enforce customary law.
  • Both make real laws, because both can enforce them.
  • Government laws cover a whole country; social laws cover one community or place.

Governmental: the UK

  • Parliament passed the Environment Act 2021
  • It sets legal targets for air, water, wildlife and waste
  • The Environment Agency checks rivers and can fine polluters

Social: a village in Fiji

  • The chief declares a tabu: no fishing on one reef for a set time
  • Village fish wardens watch the reef
  • Rule breakers are shamed or must pay the village a fine
Name the authority: When you describe a law, say who made it and who enforces it: a parliament and an agency, or a chief and the village.

Not every rule is a law. A guideline or a promise only says what should happen. A law can be enforced, so people must obey it.

Law or guideline?

  • A guideline or pledge says what should happen, but nobody is punished for ignoring it.
  • A law is binding: everyone it covers must obey it.
  • A guideline often becomes a law later, when a government adopts it.
  • So ask two questions: who made it, and can it be enforced?
Table comparing the WHO guideline and EU law on fine particles: set by a health agency v by EU governments and MEPs; 5 micrograms per cubic metre v 25, then 10 from 2030; countries need not obey v all EU members must obey; nothing happens if broken v a court case, then fines.
The same pollutant, two kinds of rule.

Real example: the WHO says yearly fine-particle pollution should stay below 5 micrograms per cubic metre, but no country is punished for going over. The EU made a binding limit of 25, falling to 10 from 2030. The European Commission can take a country that breaks it to the EU Court of Justice.

Memorize terms 3x faster

Smart flashcards show you cards right before you forget them. Perfect for definitions and key concepts.

Try Flashcards FreeYour first topic is free to keep • No credit card required

A rule only changes behaviour if it is enforced. To enforce a law, an authority checks that it is kept and applies a sanction when it is broken.

How laws are enforced

  • Monitoring: inspectors, police, wardens or cameras check that the rule is kept.
  • Fines and prison for those who break it.
  • Losing a licence, or goods taken away (confiscation).
  • Courts decide disputes and set the punishment.
  • Social penalties: public shame or exclusion from the community.

Real example: in Singapore, dropping litter can bring a fine of up to S$2,000 for a first offence. Since 1992 courts can also give a Corrective Work Order: offenders clean streets and parks in bright vests, so the public sees them. That is a legal penalty and a social one at once.

A law nobody enforces: A law with no checks and no penalties changes little. Writing a rule down is not enough: it needs people, money and courts to make it work.
How this could come up: No paper has asked this statement on its own yet. It sits inside other questions: May 2026 credited 'the rules are set by the government' as a principle of environmental law. Likely shapes: a Paper 1 part on a fact file [1-3], or Paper 2 Section B (a) [4].
IB-style questionOutline[4 marks]

Since 1992 Singapore has banned the import and sale of chewing gum, to stop gum being stuck on pavements, buses and train doors. Since 2004 gum with a health benefit may be sold by pharmacists.

Outline how Singapore's chewing gum ban shows the features of a law.

Model answer plan

See the mark-by-mark plan — for / against / judgement, with marking guidance — in study mode.

Claim your free topic

Try an IB Exam Question — Free AI Feedback

Test yourself on What laws are. Write your answer and get instant AI feedback — just like a real IB examiner.

Since 2017 Kenya has banned plastic carrier bags.

the term law.
[2 marks]

Related ESS HL Topics

Continue learning with these related topics from the same unit:

9.1.2What environmental law covers
9.1.3Environmental law, justice and lobbying
9.1.4Making environmental law work
9.1.5Environmental constitutionalism
View all ESS HL topics

Practice with flashcards

Spaced repetition flashcards for What laws are

Improve your exam technique

Command terms, paper structure, and mark-scheme tips for ESS HL

Previous
8.3.11Indirect impacts of tropospheric ozone
Next
What environmental law covers9.1.2

6 questions to test your understanding

Reading is just the start. Students who tested themselves scored 82% on average — try IB-style questions with AI feedback.

Start FreeView All ESS HL Topics